Osteoarthritis Pain vs. Rheumatoid Arthritis Pain

Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and osteoarthritis (OA) can cause considerable pain and joint problems, but they are two different types of arthritis. 

RA is an autoimmune disease that occurs when the immune system malfunctions and starts attacking healthy tissues, mainly the synovium (the linings of joints). The same inflammation affecting the joints can also damage organs, including your eyes, skin, heart, and lungs. 

Unlike RA, OA is not an autoimmune disease. You get it when articular cartilage — the smooth, white tissue at the ends of bones where they meet to form joints — breaks down. This breakdown is the result of daily wear and tear.  

“As I like to tell my patients, OA is a type of wear and tear arthritis, similar to a tire wearing down with use, whereas RA is an autoimmune disease where you try to fix the problem as closely as possible,” says Dr. Jiha Lee, a rheumatologist at the University of Michigan Health. 

These are the main differences between RA and OA. But many more differences can help your doctor determine what type of arthritis you have and your treatment options.  

More Differences

According to a 2020 report in Preventive Medicine Reports, OA affects more than 30 million U.S. adults, making it one of the most common arthritic conditions. On the other hand, RA is the most common systemic (whole-body) autoimmune disease affecting about 0.5 percent to 1.0 percent of the American population.  

Both RA and OA cause inflammation of joints, but with RA, there is much more inflammation. In recent years, researchers have found inflammation can occur in OA leading to radiographic and pain progression but are unsure of the role of inflammation and whether it is the cause of OA or the result.  

OA and RA can share some symptoms, but RA often affects multiple joints in a symmetrical (on both sides of the body) fashion. OA will affect only a few joints on one side of the body. RA also causes flu-like symptoms, such as fever and malaise (a general unwell feeling).  

Which Is Worse — RA or OA?

The progression of RA is more challenging to predict. OA tends to be more predictable as symptoms are limited to affected joints. Nonetheless, OA can still be a debilitating condition. 

Both conditions cause a lot of disability and loss of function. In the case of RA, we have treatments that can slow down the disease process and achieve remission. With OA, there is a progression over time that can lead to surgery down the road,” says Dr. Lee.  

Remission in RA generally refers to a period of no symptoms or very few symptoms. 

 RA vs. OA: Getting a Correct Diagnosis

The treatment goals for both RA and OA are similar — to maintain joint function, reduce pain, and minimize the potential for joint damage. But these conditions need to be treated and managed differently, which makes getting the correct diagnosis crucial.  

With RA, diagnosis involves a medical history, physical examination, bloodwork, and imaging studies. Your medical history in RA is helpful because there is a genetic component to the disease.  

An OA diagnosis typically involves a medical history, physical examination, and imaging studies. Bloodwork might be done to rule out RA and other types of autoimmune arthritis.  

With this overlap in diagnosis, RA is sometimes mistaken for OA — “it often happens, especially as patients get older,” Dr. Lee says. This is especially common in erosive OA. It can be mistaken at times, leading to delays in diagnosis and treatment.” Erosive OA is a rarer, more severe type of OA involving bone erosion and cartilage damage to the fingers. 

The Role of Imaging

According to Dr. Lee, X-rays, ultrasound scans, and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can help distinguish RA from OA. “They do have different patterns in terms of the joint damage that occurs.”  

Dr. Lee adds that X-rays can be less reliable early on. “Changes on X-rays take time to show up. Ultrasound and MRI can show inflammation better and point you more to OA vs. RA.” 

The different types of imaging can reveal distinct patterns of arthritic damage in both RA and OA. For example, X-rays can visualize cartilage loss, bone spurs, and other bone damage. MRI and ultrasound can offer more detailed images of soft tissues like tendons and ligaments, cartilage, and the synovial lining of joints.  

With OA, imaging can reveal joint damage in the weight-bearing joints, mainly the knees and hips. “With that, you will see joint space narrowing between the bones at the joints where cartilage has worn away,” says Dr. Lee.  

When that joint space narrowing occurs, the cartilage can no longer keep bones apart, and bones start to painfully rub against each other.  

On imaging, RA is distinguishable from OA because, according to Dr. Lee, “RA, especially in the hands and feet, leads to erosive changes at the bone.”  

Bone erosion means there is a loss of bone or bone destruction.  

Can RA and OA Co-Exist?

It is possible to have both RA and OA. OA is more likely to occur as you age, and people with RA are at risk for OA as they get older. It is also possible to have elderly-onset RA years after being diagnosed with OA.  

According to a 2018 report in the journal Therapeutic Advances in Musculoskeletal Disease, elderly onset RA, or geriatric RA, begins after age 65. It presents with more systemic symptoms (fever, malaise, etc.) and more frequently affects large joints (knees and the hips) rather than the small joints of the hands and feet. 

When these conditions co-exist, diagnosing and treating both conditions can be challenging. “Both patients and doctors have difficulty differentiating between pain caused by either condition, says Dr. Lee. “That can lead to function and mobility problems and delayed treatment.” 

Getting Prompt Treatment for RA and OA

If you have experienced signs of RA or OA, you will want to see your doctor as soon as possible. If RA diagnosis and treatment are delayed, severe joint damage can occur. Delays in an OA diagnosis and treatment could mean increased pain and stiffness and a loss of mobility.  

Fortunately, there are plenty of treatment options for both RA and OA, and some, such as nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, analgesics, and prescription pain relievers, can treat both. Immunosuppressive therapies, including methotrexate and biologics, can slow down the effects of the immune system and reduce inflammation. RA and OA are also managed by following a healthy lifestyle, including exercise, weight loss, proper nutrition, and stress management.  

Want to Get More Involved with Patient Advocacy?

The 50-State Network is the grassroots advocacy arm of CreakyJoints and the Global Healthy Living Foundation, comprised of patients with chronic illness who are trained as health care activists to proactively connect with local, state, and federal health policy stakeholders to share their perspectives and influence change. If you want to effect change and make health care more affordable and accessible to patients with chronic illness, learn more here. 

Interview with Dr. Jiha Lee, a rheumatologist at the University of Michigan Health. 

Kobak S, Bes C. An autumn tale: Geriatric rheumatoid arthritis. Ther Adv Musculoskelet Dis. 2018;10(1):3-11. doi: https://doi.org/10.1177/1759720X17740075. 

Mohammed A, et al. A comparison of risk factors for osteo- and rheumatoid arthritis using NHANES data. Prev Med Rep. Nov 5, 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pmedr.2020.101242.  

Sanchez-Lopez E, et al. Synovial inflammation in osteoarthritis progression. Nat Rev Rheumatol. May 2022. doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41584-022-00749-9.  

  • Was This Helpful?